How to Price Vinyl, CDs and Cassettes
Price vinyl, CDs, and cassettes from the complete delivered offer: landed inventory, platform and payment fees, pick and pack, packing materials, postage subsidy, replacement and refund reserve, channel discount, taxes or duties the seller absorbs, and campaign allocation. Calculate a price floor for each sales channel, then test buyer value and contribution without hiding shipping inside optimistic margin.
Lead visual
The useful number is net
Revenue
streams, merch, fans, grants
+
Costs
production, ads, team, tax
-
Net
what the project keeps
=
Direct-to-fan · Manufacturing
Business model map
Use this for
Separate revenue, margin, cash timing, and ownership before calling something profitable.
Watch for
Top-line income can hide a model that does not leave enough money or time for the artist.
Check
Price, platform fees, fulfillment cost, tax, collaborator splits, and repeat-purchase behavior.
Result
A sharper view of which money path is worth building next.
current Bandcamp physical-goods share
current typical Bandcamp processing range
direct, show, and wholesale ledgers
minimum sustainable price per channel
What belongs in the physical-format price floor?
Velveteen full-cost pricing model
Nine inputs before buyer-value testing
Item
Landed usable-unit cost after manufacturing, inbound freight, tax/duties, and preparation.
Replaces the incomplete factory unit line with received inventory cost.
Channel
Platform, payment, marketplace, retailer, distributor, or consignment costs and timing.
Prevents one direct-store margin from being reused for every channel.
Handling
Pick/pack labour, packing materials, inserts, labels, and order-system cost.
Prices the work required to turn stock into an accurate shipment.
Shipping
Buyer charge, seller subsidy, destination/weight variance, tracking, and combined-order rule.
Shows when a simple buyer offer transfers postage risk to the seller.
Exceptions
Defect, replacement, loss, damage, refund, chargeback, and customer-support reserve.
Keeps normal failure costs from appearing as a surprise loss.
Tax
Tax collected, remitted, included, or absorbed, plus duties under the actual selling model.
Separates collected money from revenue the artist can keep.
Campaign
Allocated photography, store setup, advertising, launch materials, and promotion.
Connects product contribution to the cost of creating the demand.
Contribution
Net amount per sold unit after every variable cost, not gross markup.
Creates the amount that can actually recover fixed launch cost.
Value
Edition, packaging, scarcity claim, bundle, experience, and evidence buyers accept the offer.
Tests whether the sustainable floor is also a credible buyer price.
How should one format be stress-tested across channels?
| Add to the model | Failure to avoid | |
|---|---|---|
| Direct store | Platform/payment fees, packing, postage, support, tax, and returns | Calling item price minus factory cost the margin |
| Live show | Payment fee, tax, transport, venue cut where applicable, and shrinkage | Treating cash sales as costless inventory |
| Wholesale | Discount, outbound freight, minimum, payment timing, returns, and bad debt | Using the direct retail contribution after a retailer discount |
| Bundle | Every component, extra weight, packing time, split shipment, and replacement path | Pricing the bundle from the headline value of its parts |
Keep item price and shipping visible
A separate shipping charge improves cost visibility but can affect conversion. A bundled or free-shipping offer simplifies the buyer view but transfers variance to the seller. Test the commercial choice without erasing the underlying postage ledger.
turn the chosen channel price into release-level cash and break-even
Which sources support the pricing controls?
Frequently asked questions
How much should an artist charge for vinyl?+
There is no universal price. Calculate the direct-store, show, and wholesale floors from the specific edition's landed inventory and channel costs, then compare the complete offer with what its buyers value. Premium packaging can support a higher price only if the audience wants it; a high retail price does not repair an oversized pressing.
How should CDs and cassettes be priced?+
Use the same full-cost method as vinyl, with format-specific landed cost, packaging, handling, shipping, defects, channel fees, and buyer value. Do not apply one markup percentage to every format. A compact item may cost less to mail, while a small custom run can still have significant setup and per-unit cost.
Should music artists offer free shipping?+
Only as an explicit pricing choice. Free shipping moves the expected postage and part of its variance into item margin or campaign cost. Model destination mix, package weight and dimensions, tracking policy, remote surcharges, international exclusions, combined orders, and replacement exposure before advertising it. Review actual shipping variance after launch.
How do wholesale prices affect physical music margins?+
Wholesale introduces a retailer or distributor discount and may add freight, returns, payment timing, or consignment risk. Build a separate channel ledger rather than subtracting the discount from a direct-sale margin. Set minimum quantities and terms, and confirm that the wholesale contribution still supports production cash, operations, and replacements.
What fees apply to physical music on Bandcamp?+
Bandcamp's current revenue share is 10% on physical goods, with shipping and tax excluded from that fee base. Payment processing is separate and typically 4% to 6%. Treat those as current Bandcamp inputs only, verify the live account and fee page, and model other storefronts or payment methods independently.
Get better release strategy in your inbox
Release planning checklists, royalty explainers, and artist strategy notes from Velveteen. No daily noise.
Was this useful? Send a signal or flag a correction.
Keep reading
Pillar guide
Physical music releases
An eight-gate field guide for choosing, manufacturing, receiving, pricing, and fulfilling vinyl, CDs, and cassettes without turning estimates into promises.
Related guide
Vinyl quantity and break-even
An evidence-to-quantity gate and constructed 300-unit ledger that exposes landed cost, channel fees, order costs, contribution, and downside.
Related guide
Bandcamp pricing and pay what you want
A four-option pricing model with current 15%/10% revenue shares, typical 4% to 6% processing, pay-more observations, and constructed gross-to-net math.
Put real numbers on your release
Enter a budget and get a recommended split across content, ads, PR, and creative, with warnings on the line items where indie spend usually goes fragile.